Showing posts with label ROI. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ROI. Show all posts

September 14, 2011

The Goal: A Process of Ongoing Improvement

The following Book Review has received II Prize in the Book Review Competition held at Indian Institute of Management, Raipur
Introduction
‘The Goal’ – an operations and supply chain oriented novel was first published in 1984. It is written by Dr E Goldratt (physicist by training and management consultant by occupation) and takes a novel approach of explaining the eventual reason (goal) for the existence of an organisation/company. Also it aims to help the readers realise the methods of improving the profitability and functioning of any company.

Plot
The main character of the novel is Alex Rogo, who is the plant manager of UniCo manufacturing. The plant is riddled with problems like excess unshipped inventory, orders frequently behind the schedule and labour dissent. All this is happening inspite of advanced machinery being present in the plant. The Company executive issues an ultimatum of three months to Alex to turn around the plant or to face shutdown. Deep in crisis, Alex turns to Jonah, who helps him realise the bottlenecks in production, after removal of which the plant will return to profitability.
Analysis
The book is a continuous series of conversations between Alex and Jonah. It is interesting to note that, in spite of knowing the answers Jonah never passes them on to Alex. He urges Alex to arrive at them through a series of well directed questions. This method is known as the ‘Socratic method’, in which the instructor engages the pupil in dialogue and encourages him to think and deliberate about the problems at hand and arrive at conclusions by eliminating the irrelevant choices.
By writing the book as a series of conversations, Goldratt believes that the reader will be able to arrive at the answers before Alex. To quote Goldratt himself – “This is the way we should attempt to write our textbooks. Our textbooks should not present us with a series of end results but rather a plot that enables the reader to go through the deduction process himself. If I succeed by this book to change somewhat your perception of science and education, this is my true reward.”
The argument here is that we can only learn through our own deductive processes. If we are presented with readymade facts then we are ‘trained’ and not ‘learned’. No exceptional intelligence is required for deduction and logic. The idea of the book is to encourage the reader to critically analyse any problem and not just attack it with the existing conventions because "that's the way it was always done".

Leanings
The book very lucidly explains the Theory of Constraints and how to resolve bottlenecks. Also explained in the book are the real parameters of any business which any manager should focus on. The business world today is filled with enough jargon to confuse anybody, viz - cost-effective purchasing, employing good people, high technology, producing products, producing quality products, selling quality products, capturing market share. In this mess the manager forgets the actual ‘Goal’ of the business, and that is:
·         Higher Net Profit – as the real aim of any business is to make money.
·         High Return on Investment (ROI) – as higher the returns higher the profits.
·         Regular and Positive Cash flows – to run day to day tasks and prevent the business from accumulating debt.
Dr. Ashwin Kumar Narayankar, a student of Indian Insttitute of Management, Raipur has done his M.B.B.S. from Lokmanya Tilak Municipal Medical College, Mumbai.
The Book Review of the Winner of the Book Review Competition will be published in the Half Yearly Magazine. To request a copy of the magazine, mail us at opep@iimraipur.ac.in 

May 01, 2011

How are Procter & Gamble’s Supply Chain Strategies better than their Competitors’?

 
Procter & Gamble has established itself as a market leader as a result of certain strategies it applies on its products’ Supply Chains and that impact directly on those Supply Chains.  For example, as stated in its Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats (SWOT) Analysis, it focuses on acquisitions of companies and products that are already good performers, with reasonable demands for these products, and that are already well-established in the market place.  Such products, to have become well-established, are themselves the result of good, efficiently-run Supply Chains.  Therefore, these Supply Chains enable their products to be sold at competitive prices to their intended markets.
If the Supply Chains operate inefficiently, the products resulting from them would require artificially higher selling prices to recover the excess costs resulting from those Supply Chains.  These excess costs would therefore result in reduced demands for the products in their marketplaces.  Consumers would therefore go for the less expensive alternatives, which would more than likely not be products manufactured and distributed by Procter & Gamble.  Thus, for Procter & Gamble to achieve Competitive Advantage over its competitors, its best interest would lie in its ability to focus on products well-established and accepted by the markets, and produced from efficient, well-run Supply Chains.
Procter & Gamble also earmark their products for redevelopment and consolidation, with a view to broadening their consumer base on a reduced number of products, per product type.  To enable this, Procter & Gamble subject their products to controlled investigations by well-qualified and experienced scientists.  These scientists would not approve them for release unless the products are tried and proven, are focused towards being innovative, and are capable of addressing the requirements of the extended or broadened market.
Procter & Gamble also has a drive to reducing its Capital spending to a certain percentage of Sales.  This Capital may in fact be part of the Supply Chain.  On achieving this, there would be a further reduction associated with, for example, Supply Chain costs, and that consumers should benefit from, as a result of reduced product prices.
Procter & Gamble also drive to concentrate on and build up their core businesses and leading brands into stronger market leaders.  Currently, Procter & Gamble has four core categories, Fabric Care, Hair Care, Baby Care and Feminine Care.  As these core businesses attract nearly 50% of its sales and larger profits, Procter & Gamble devote considerable energies to maintain these strong, and takes steps to help them grow.  In addition to developing close working relationships with its customers and main suppliers, it focuses on inventory–reduction schemes, cost reduction processes and increases in the Return on Investments (ROI) in marketing and in new products.  It also develops value–generating activities throughout the entire Supply Chain, for each of its core products, through for example, the pooling of knowledge, expertise, and reach. 
According to Procter & Gamble’s CEO, George D. Carpenter, the Company has made products more affordable to consumer markets in less developed countries lacking large–scale Supply Chains and distribution efficiencies, evident in fully developed countries.  For example, in the Philippines, Procter & Gamble has developed a job creation scheme that gets products to consumers originally not able to buy their products, through a “Reach, Distribution, and Livelihood Program”.  This Program involves “the delivery of products to people living in remote areas or whose local stores are too small or inaccessible to receive stock” [Procter & Gamble 2003 Sustainability Report].  After five months in operation, 580 jobs had been created and an additional 28,000 stores were selling Procter & Gamble products, with local distributors earning margins of 1%.
In Brazil, Procter & Gamble decided that to better understand local, domestic households, they would need to live in them and be a part of the locals’ lives.  They teamed up with the local food industry leaders, Sadia, to implement a program they would call “Living It” [Procter & Gamble 2003 Sustainability Report].  Under this scheme, Procter & Gamble staff would live in local Brazilian homes for two weeks, trying to better understand family and community life.  Through this scheme, Procter & Gamble were able to work on new products and distribution systems, as well as find better ways of communicating with its consumers.
Conclusion
Procter & Gamble are truly a global organization, operating plants all over the world. These plants are also used for job creation in developing areas.  As Procter & Gamble make many different products according to many different categories, their competitors are plentiful; although there is no single, direct competitor, in 100% of its product lines, services, and activities.  There are only many different competitors that compete on any one or more of different product lines.
Supply Chain Management is integral to creating and maintaining Competitive Advantage.  Procter & Gamble have done this by aligning many of their accounts with suppliers and by initiating change in their overall Supply Chain structure; such that they now call it a network as it allows for communication between each and every level rather than only according to a flow-on fashion.  They have brought a change about in their system to be what they are today.  Procter & Gamble attribute this success of theirs to their way of managing the Supply Chain.  Hence we can say that managing Supply Chains in an effective style will definitely help organisations by giving it a Competitive Advantage over its rivals.
References
Datamonitor (2004), Proctor & Gamble Company profile.
Day, C.R. (1993), Turn up the thermostat, Industry Week, 242(16) pp.38-41.
http://www.computerworld.com/softwaretopics/erp/story/0,10801,77855,00.html
http://www.manufacturing.net/scm/article/CA202086
http://books.nap.edu/books/0309068789/html/24.html
http://www.computerworld.com/computerworld/records/images/pdf/P_Gs_Supply_
Network.pdf
http://www.cisco.com/warp/public/779/ibs/solutions/customer/pgcasestudy1.pdf
http://www.manufacturing.net/scm/article/CA85844?stt=%25stt&pubdate=4%2F1%2F2004
Procter & Gamble Sustainability Report (2003), http://www.pg.com/.
 Harshad Patil has done his B.Tech. from Veermata Jijabhai Technological Institute, Mumbai and can be reached at eharshad @ gmail . com